![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
A recently published paper from CIHM asks the question, How much does mindfulness matter?
This active control intervention is called the Health Enhancement Program (HEP). In research using this active comparison intervention, participants were randomly placed in either an MBSR course or a HEP course. "The key to HEP was creating a program that genuinely promotes health and well-being, being delivered by experts in their field, who believe in what they are teaching. The goal was to create MBSR minus the mindfulness. HEP is about as close as we can get." For instance, HEP offered participants functional movement instead of yoga, physical activity instead of walking meditation and music-based imagery instead of body scans. And the benefits of HEP, researchers found, are quite similar to that of MBSR on questionnaire measures. "We found that for most of our self-report measures, it didn't matter whether a participant was in the MBSR course or the HEP course. This suggests that while MBSR offers ways to decrease stress and enhance well-being, it's not the only way. HEP provides similar benefits." With other measures, researchers did find some key differences. For instance, MBSR participants reported less reactivity to pain than those in HEP. There were also differences in immune response to stressful events, a finding to be reported in another upcoming publication from CIHM scientist Melissa Rosenkranz, PhD. So, what does this mean for mindfulness? "If we look at self-report measures frequently used in past research, the conclusion is clear," says MacCoon. "Mindfulness is not better than ingredients that may be present in HEP. But the immune results suggest that we may need measures more sensitive and specific to uncover benefits specific to mindfulness itself." MacCoon highlights two advantages of research now possible with HEP. First, HEP represents a severe test for MBSR: "Any differences we find between MBSR and HEP have gone through the scientific ringer and come out the other side of a very strong test," says MacCoon. "The results that survive should be very interesting for the mindfulness community." When talking about the second advantage, MacCoon concludes, "MBSR is certainly a beneficial tool, but we're also learning more about how other programs like HEP can bring about the same benefits for people. This is actually good news. It means there are multiple ways to live a healthy life and we've essentially identified one more alternative or approach. At the same time, we've also created a research tool that more accurately pinpoints when mindfulness is making the difference." Developing this active control was an important foundation for CIHM's larger study that is supported by the The National Institutes of Health, National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). Click here to learn more about the NCCAM study. To learn more about MacCoon's study, click here and to learn more about HEP guidelines, click here. This paper will appear in the Behaviour Research & Therapy Journal. Title: The validation of an active control intervention for Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Other CIHM Research Heading to Publication Daniel Levinson, CIHM graduate student Mind wandering is easy to come by, but is it free? This study finds that mind wandering may actually use up our attention, and if you have good working memory (keeping multiple things in mind while simultaneously performing complex tasks), you're probably going to wander more when performing simple tasks. Contrary to the notion that a wandering mind may be a free mind, this research suggests it's actually quite tied up. While thinking about tomorrow's plans and future goals, you're less able to pay attention to the experience at hand - a game with your child or a run in the park, for example. So, Levinson suggests it may boil down to how you balance the use of your mental resources. Mind wandering can provide the opportunity to envision your future, which could perhaps lead to clarity and perspective. And yet a healthy reprieve from over-thinking can free your mind to enjoy the life right in front of you. This paper will appear in Psychological Science. Title: The Persistence of Thought: Evidence for a Role of Working Memory in the Maintenance of Task-Unrelated Thinking |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
A UW-Madison Collaborative Workshop: Living Fully What if you found out you only had one year left to live? How would your perspective change? And what would you begin to value? Perhaps you'd look for ways to laugh more, have fun and just be present in the moment. And yet, for most of us, our daily reality is focused on working harder and balancing more, constantly challenging our ability to pause and enjoy life. Our minds are becoming accustomed to thinking ahead and losing track of the moment. By participating in the Living Fully workshop, you can
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
www.investigatinghealthyminds.org
Forward this email to a Friend Waisman Center | 1500 Highland Avenue | Madison, Wisconsin | 608.890.3074 |